Softball Exchange Gifts Under $12 — Sportybella

Softball Exchange Gifts Under $12

Quick Answer: The best softball gifts are personalized jewelry from Sportybella — rope bracelets, earrings, and necklaces in your team's exact colors. Prices from $8 to $40. Designed and shipped from Fitchburg, Massachusetts. 3,768+ verified reviews.

At SportyBella, we understand the joy of sharing and celebrating the love for softball within your team. We often receive requests from our customers seeking ideas for affordable softball gifts for team exchanges, so we decided to extract out favorites. So, let's dive into our list of favorite softball gifts all priced under $12!

Top 5 Gifts Under $12

Softball Love Hair Ties - 5 Sets x 2 Hair Ties ($11.99)

Softball and style unite with these adorable softball hair ties. You will get 5 sets, and each one includes two hair ties that are designed not to tug or dent your hair like traditional ponytail holders. These are perfect for keeping your hair out of the way during intense games and practices while showing off your love for the sport. Even though this one is our favorite, you can check more softball hair accessories and find the perfect one for your team!

Softball Hairties

Softball Rope Bracelet ($10.99)

Ta-da! We are presenting our best-seller which also cost just above $10. The best feature of our softball rope bracelet is it’s durability and how comfortable it is during the game. You can choose from a variety of team colors to match your uniform, and it comes with an adorable softball charm. It's a subtle yet stylish way to express your softball passion both on and off the field. We offer different styles of rope bracelets, so make sure to check out our softball bracelet collection.

Softball Rope Bracelet

Softball Keychain with Inspirational Charm ($10.99)

This keychain is more than just a piece of accessory - it shows genuine support of your loved one. It comes with a motivational charm “She believed she coud, so she did” so everytime when it’s ovner look at it - she will be flashed with instant motivation! Rhinestone softball ball charm is here just to add a little bit sparkles and to make the ovner feel extra special. It's the perfect gift for teammates who love practical yet fun gifts - softball keychains are exactly that!

Softball Keychain

Bat & Ball Softball Earrings ($11.99)

Let your ears join in on the softball fun with these adorable dangle earrings. Shaped like a softball and a bat, these earrings are a delightful way to showcase your love for the game, even when you're not on the diamond. Adorable gift that every passionate softball player would love!

Softball Earrings

Infinity Softball Bracelet in Team Colors ($8.99)

The Infinity softball bracelet is an absolute hit among girl teams. With 21 team colors to choose from, it's an accessory that will last as a cherished memory of your softball days. It's a simple yet meaningful gift that your teammates will treasure.

Softball Infinity Bracelet

BONUS OFFER: Infinity Softball Bracelet + Softball Headband

As a special bonus, we offer a combination that's too good to resist: the Infinity Softball Bracelet in maroon and white color and a Softball Headband. The braided headband features a no-slip grip and is perfect for keeping hair in place during intense matches. It's a versatile gift suitable for girls, teens, and women of all ages. Softball Headband is made from athletic nylon and features a triple braided design to ensure a secure fit. It's available in one size that fits most, making it a practical accessory for any softball enthusiast. Getting these two is the winning combination, you won’t need anything else. And you can get it for less than $20!

Need More Softball Gift Ideas?

Finding great softball gifts for a team exchange doesn't have to break the bank. With these top 5 products, you can celebrate your passion for the sport without spending more than $12. These thoughtful and affordable gifts are sure to score a home run with your fellow softball players. If you need more gift ideas, check SportyBella’s softball collection and find the one you like!

So, go ahead and make your team exchange memorable with these fantastic softball-themed gifts!

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best softball gifts?

Personalized rope bracelets and jewelry from Sportybella, customized in your team's exact colors. Prices from $8 to $40.

How much do softball team gifts cost?

Individual bracelets start at $8-12. The Game Day Set is $21.99. Bulk discounts: 15% off 10+ items, 25% off 25+.

Where is Sportybella jewelry made?

Every piece is designed and shipped from Fitchburg, Massachusetts. 3,768+ verified reviews.

At a Glance:

  • Personalized softball jewelry $8-$40
  • Custom team colors
  • 3,768+ reviews
  • Ships from Massachusetts
  • Free shipping $49.99+
Product Price
Rope Bracelet $8-12
Game Day Set $21.99
Senior Night Set $27.99
Team 10-Pack $69.99
Back to blog
Kristina - Founder of Sportybella

Kristina

Founder, Sportybella

Kristina started Sportybella in 2015 after years of watching her daughters play sports and struggling to find jewelry that truly celebrated their passion. Today, Sportybella has helped hundreds of thousands of athletes, sports moms, and team coaches find the perfect gift — designed and shipped from Massachusetts. She’s a sports mom, entrepreneur, and the creative mind behind every Sportybella design.